Friends' Work

Top Articles

Watch the Peat Petition
Friends of the Irish Environment - Watch the Peat Petition
If you only have time to look at one thing on our site, we would recommend the video of our presentation of our petition against peat cutting - domestic and industrial - and the comments of the Commission and MEPs. Recorded Tuesday 22 November 2011, this will give you heart that environmental voices can actually be heared at the highest level - and that Europe has reached the end of the line with Ireland's official denials of its continued breaches of European environmental law. 

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 26/11/2011 ( Reads : 51 ) | Comments (0)
CALL FOR ORAL HEARING ON AQUACULTURE
Friends of the Irish Environment - CALL FOR ORAL HEARING ON AQUACULTUREFIE has appealed a licensce for more expansion of the mussel industry in Dunmnanus Bay. We cite the Marine Institute's recognition that toxic contamination continues in Kenmare, Bantry and Dunmanus Bays when it excluded these bays from a reduced sampling programe in November 2011.

In our appeal, we point out that the proposal will undermine the local communities who are developing a comprehensive development plan for the area.

We also point out that failing to allow the public to comment until after the decision is made is contrary to the Aarhus Convention and EU law and that the fee of more than €150 is a barrier to public participation.

To date, the Aquaculture Appeals Board has never granted a request for an Oral Hearing.

Read the Appeal   |   Press Release

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 02/02/2012 ( Reads : 2 ) | Comments (0) | Fish farming
Is the Peatland Council doing its job?
Friends of the Irish Environment - Is the Peatland Council doing its job?FIE's submission to the Peatlands Council's Public Consultation questions if the Council is meeting its terms of reference or simply sending the fool further with yet another consultation period. Has the Council advised on the recent scientific and policy review BOGLANDS by the EPA? Has the Council clarified Ireland's 'obligations to protect key habitats'? Has it determined the available assistance from the State? All of these were part of its terms of reference - as well as this public consultation on a national peatlands policy.

Read the Submission

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 26/01/2012 ( Reads : 8 ) | Comments (0) | Protected Areas
DOUBLING OF SHEEP STOCKING APPEALED TO EU
Friends of the Irish Environment - DOUBLING OF SHEEP STOCKING APPEALED TO EUFIE has escalated its campaign to prevent the doubling of stocking rates on Ireland's Disadvantaged Areas, much of which are the sensitive mountains and blanket bogs of rural Ireland.

We have appealed to the EU Agricultural Commissioner Dacian Ciolos to refuse Ireland's request to increase the rate on the grounds that the proposal undermines the Minister for Agriculture's assurance that the intensification of agricultural to meet ambitious 2020 production targets can be done sustainably.

Basing payments on stocking rates rather than areas farmed is biased against the smaller less intensive farmer who protect the environment and is against the proposal to reform CAP payments post 2013.

High stocking rates have led in the past to a host of environmental problems, including erosion, eutrophication, soil degradation, and increased carbon emissions. This damage was confirmed by the European Court of Justice in 2002 in a judgement against Ireland.

See the letter to the CommissionerRead the Press Release

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 18/01/2012 ( Reads : 12 ) | Comments (0) | EU Commission
Objection to States largest windfarm lodged
Friends of the Irish Environment - Objection to States largest windfarm lodged

 FIE has lodged a comprehensive objection for what could be the largest wind farm in the State.

The proposal is for 45 wind turbines 126 metres in height located at Shragh near Doonbeg in County Clare, where 13 turbines have been constructed or approved already.

The development does not comply with the Wind Farm Strategy 2011 - 2017 of the Clare County Development Plan, the National Wind Farm Guidelines, the EU Guidance on wind energy development in accordance with the EU nature legislation, the Strategic Environmental Assessment for the area, the Birds and Habitats Directives and the Wildlife Acts.

'For developers to continue to press proposals that are against the specific assessments undertaken by the Local Authority is a return to the bad planning free-for-all that has cost the country dearly over the last decade.'

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 05/01/2012 ( Reads : 46 ) | Comments (0) | Wind turbines
Council proposal over Haulbowline inadequate
Friends of the Irish Environment - Council proposal over Haulbowline inadequateFIE has written to the European Commission expressing renewed concerns over the ongoing pollution from the abandoned steel works on Haulbowline Island. At a meeting on the island last month with the European Commission, Cork County Council, and the Department of the Environment, FIE found that the proposed licensce will be limited to the 9 hectares of the East Tip dump only. Numerous reports have shown that contaminated waste is wide spread across the 12 hectares of the old steel works site, both in historic dumps and through the build up of waste from the steel making itself.

 The clear identification of contaminated waste at the site of the steelworks which was revealed in the consultants White Young Green Report in 2005 was redacted from their subsequent 2008 Report on which the authorities are basing the licence application. Any licensce application must address the contaminated waste on the entire 20 hectare site to ensure the safety of the public and the environment.

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 23/12/2011 ( Reads : 27 ) | Comments (0) | EU Commission
Minister warned on doubling of stocking rates
Friends of the Irish Environment - Minister warned on doubling of stocking rates FIE has written to the Minister for Agriculture Simon Coveney asking him to reconsider the new requirement for hill farmers to double their stocking rates to qualify for grant payments. Changes recently announced to the Disadvantaged Area Scheme which includes 100,000 farmers, require them to double their stocking rate from one sheep to two per hectare.

High stocking rates got Ireland condemned by the EU Court of Justice. At that time Ireland promised REPS and cuts to stocking rates and the introcution of REPS to meet the requirement to maintain the 'ecological needs of habitats inside and outside the protected zones'

Now REPs is closed and funding has been allocated to its replacement, AEOS. There is a clear danger that the factors which brought Ireland before the Court of Justice ten years ago are coming back again.

We have also asked the Minister to reverse the Exclusion of non-breeding horses from stocking density calculations. This will encourage breeding of horses when there is a current serious surplus in Ireland.

 Press Release   Letter to Minister

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 14/12/2011 ( Reads : 32 ) | Comments (0) | Protected Areas
EU TO INVESTIGATE EXTENSION OF IRISH SLURRY SPREADING SEASON
Friends of the Irish Environment - EU TO INVESTIGATE EXTENSION OF IRISH SLURRY SPREADING SEASONDECISION IGNORED EU COMMISSIONER RULING

The European Commission has responded to our complaint over the decision of the Minister for the Environment and the Minister for Agriculture to extend the 2011 slurry spreading season for two weeks beyond the Irish Regulations, which requires an end to slurry spreading by October 15th every year.

This had been specifically forbidden in January 2011 by the European Commission for the Environment, J. Potocnik.

Adding weight to the complaint, we cite the recent EPA 2010 water data monitoring figures which show an increase in exceedences of the nitrate parametric value from 16 supplies in 2009 to 19 supplies in 2010. The population affected by nitrate exceedences increased more than 4 fold. Ireland now has the highest rate in Europe of two of the diseases caused by slurry in drinking water, cryptosporidium and STEC [e.coli].

During FIE's recent Petition to the European Parliament, Danish MEP Margrete Auken told the EU Petitions Committee that 'you get the feeling that we have the EU at the moon or somewhere and what is going on in Ireland doesn't bother anybody outside.'

PRESS RELEASE     |        READ THE COMPLAINT

See panel below for documentation

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 12/12/2011 ( Reads : 34 ) | Comments (0) | EU Commission
FIE PEAT CUTTING PETITION TO EU
The EU Commissioner for the Environment J. Potocnik attended  the meeting of the EU Parliament's Petitions Committee when FIE's petition seeking the Commissions assistance to protect Ireland's peatlands was heard.

The Petition seeks the Commissions assistance in ending not only the turf cutting taking place on special areas of conservation, but also the unlicensed and unregulated industrial extraction which is continuing across the midlands. FIE is making a formal request for the Petitions Committee to come to Ireland on a fact-finding mission. ‘If Committee members see first-hand what is happening, we believe they will be strongly motivated to act.'

SEE FIE'S PRESENTATION TO THE COMMITTEE AS RECORDED LIVE

 

Read the Speaking Notes   |   See The Petition itself   |  And the supplementary report on turf cutting in protected sites with photographs

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 22/11/2011 ( Reads : 49 ) | Comments (0) | EU Commission
MINISTER DEFIED EU COMMISSIONER ON SLURRY SPREADING
Friends of the Irish Environment - MINISTER DEFIED EU COMMISSIONER ON SLURRY SPREADINGFIE has found that in spite of an unequivocal statement by the European Commissioner for the Environment that no extension to the slurry spreading season be permitted in Ireland, the Minister for the Environment extended this period into the last two weeks of October. This period saw some of the heaviest rainfall in Irish history, washing the slurry into drinking water sources across Ireland.

Ireland now has the highest rate in Europe of two of the diseases caused by slurry in drinking water, cryptosporidium and STEC [e.coli]. With only token set-backs of 2 metres from our drinking water abstraction bodies, contamination of water supplies by slurry spreading is creating a direct danger to public health and consequent cost to the health service.

The group has written to the European Commissioner and to the Minister for Health, Dr. James O'Reilly.

With ever increasing production, farmers must be required to use separation or anaerobic digesters on this ‘waste' to reduce the need for slurry spreading and prevent the health risks of contamination of the country's drinking water.

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 15/11/2011 ( Reads : 49 ) | Comments (0) | Water quality
Review of the EPA dropped?
Friends of the Irish Environment - Review of the EPA dropped?The recently announced appointment of a long standing Director of the EPA, however competent, to the top EPA post will mitigate against the implementation of the recommendations of the 2011 ‘Review of the Environmental Protection Agency'.

This review was a major achievement of the last Government and in fact even includes key recommendations for a review of the composition of the selection committee that recommended this appointment to the Minister. The Review was intended to ensure the independence and competence of the agency and it is worrying that this appointment for 7 years has been made by the Minister without any cognisance of the Review Groups' recommendations.'

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 10/11/2011 ( Reads : 48 ) | Comments (0) | Politics
Ireland's contaminated drinking water
Friends of the Irish Environment - Ireland's contaminated drinking waterFIE's work on analysing the failure by Local Authorities to provide clean and wholesome drinking water has shown that 1,153,732 people are receiving water that is seriously and persistently over the legal parameters. These supplies have been placed by the EPA on the Remedial Action List which the law requires the public to be notified - but there has been virtually no public notification whatsoever. And the Remedial Action List only reveals public supplies in need of urgent action. No mention is made of private or public group water schemes which cover a further 500,000 people and are generally poorer in quality.

Read about this in the Irish Times. |   Read our Press Briefing  |  See the top ten problems, from cryptosporidium to disinfectant by products  |  Read our request to the EPA to remove the password protection from their on-line databases that is concealing then true state of our drinking water from the public. Contact us if you want to know about the water quality in your area. admin@friendsoftheirishenvironment.org

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 07/11/2011 ( Reads : 53 ) | Comments (0) | Water quality
Countryside protection
Friends of the Irish Environment - Countryside protection

FIE has made three major submissions to recent Government consultations.

On waste, the consultation document “Towards a new National Waste Policy Discussion Document” ignored more than three years of work. The “International Review of Waste Management Policy”, published in 2009 with 65 Annexes, the largest waste policy study ever undertaken in Ireland, at significant cost to the taxpayer, by an international consultancy was effectively ignored in the consultation document. 

Two further submissions relate to the C-66/06 Judgment of the European Court of Justice about activities in the countryside that damage the environment. The Government has moved controls for assessment of hedgerows, archaeological monuments and land use changes from the Department of the Environment to the Department of Agriculture, who do not have the skills for this work and who have production targets to meet that conflict with environmental protection.

The Department of the Environment has kept the protection of wetlands under its own control – and that of peat extraction – but has left a threshold for wetland assessments that effectively deregulates a significant proportion of wetlands in Ireland, including most ponds, springs, streams, dune slacks and wet woodland relics and could significantly undermine the conservation function of larger wetlands.

The failure to undertake a Regulatory Impact Analysis is a central concern of FIE's submission as this would have highlighted the problems.

Waste policy consultation    |   New EIA Regulations C-66/06 Agriculture

 |   New EIA Regulations C-66/06 Environment

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 04/11/2011 ( Reads : 43 ) | Comments (0) | Day to Day Diary
SEPTIC TANK LEGISLATION 'IRRESPONSIBLE'
Friends of the Irish Environment - SEPTIC TANK LEGISLATION 'IRRESPONSIBLE'Friends of the Irish Environment said the proposal risk based inspection programme for septic tanks would not meet the terms of the European judgment.

‘The model used in County Cavan which was specifically singled out as satisfactory in the Judgment of the European Court requires that all septic tanks are registered and inspected at periodic intervals. The Government's proposal does not meet that standard and so risks further infringement proceedings, as well as leaving the environment at risk from the estimated one-third of the 400,000 septic tanks across Ireland that are currently polluting the environment.

The omission of a requirement to inspect septic tanks in new dwellings and those being sold is particularly irresponsible.'

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 04/11/2011 ( Reads : 55 ) | Comments (0) | Water quality
Rejection of commercial sea bass fishing welcomed
Friends of the Irish Environment - Rejection of commercial sea bass fishing welcomedFIE has welcomed Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Simon Coveney, TD, decision to refuse the Federation of Irish Fishermen's [FIF] request to allow the commercial fishing of sea bass in the Celtic Sea.

The Minister has confirmed to FIE that he is ‘not proposing changes at this time to the current arrangements in relation to bass fishing.'

The confirmation comes after FIE had requested documentation relating to the advice the Minister had received on the 2009 request.

Read the Press Release

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 18/10/2011 ( Reads : 64 ) | Comments (0) | Fisheries
TURF CUTTERS: NGOS SEEK DRAIN BLOCKING
Friends of the Irish Environment - TURF CUTTERS: NGOS SEEK DRAIN BLOCKINGAngry at the Government's new Regulations and hard line on the end to turf cutting on protected bogs, the Turf Cutters have withdraw from the Government's mediation structure, the Peatland's Council.

Minister for the Environment Phil Hogan is reported to have told councillors in Sligo that there was no possibility of turf cutting continuing within the existing boundaries of the SACs. ‘The SACs are gone', he is reported to have said.

FIE has called on the Government to use new powers to take immediate action to block the drainage network which is currently degrading these bog lands. Immediately, after drain closure, the natural water table of the bogs will begin to rise and the habitat be gradually be restored to its natural state.

‘If this drainage is stopped, not only will the conservation process begin but by next spring most of the affected bogs will be so wet that it will be impossible to bring heavy machinery into them. Not to begin the blocking of drains now will only allow the damage to continue but will facilitate the cutters proposed illegal actions.'

Full Press Release | Media coverage

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 30/09/2011 ( Reads : 77 ) | Comments (0) | Protected Areas
Petroleum Safety Framework
Friends of the Irish Environment - Petroleum Safety Framework FIE has called on the Government to ensure that the word ‘environment' is included in the High Level Design of the Petroleum Safety Framework for Ireland. In a submission to the consultation period, FIE has asked that the word ‘safety' be defined in the legislation and that in addition to specifying protection for ‘life', the ‘environment' is also specifically named for protection.

The submission also seeks to ensure that any proposed legislation ensures that the Access to Information on the Environment Directive and Irish Regulations are respected. This means that in regard to emissions to the environment, there are no cases in which this information may be refused to the public. It also means that every decision not to release any other environmental information on grounds of commercial confidentiality or security must be required to be weighed against the public interest.

Read the submission.

 

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 27/09/2011 ( Reads : 81 ) | Comments (0) | Press Release
Turf Cutting Debate
Friends of the Irish Environment - Turf Cutting Debate

Turf Cutters' and Contractors' Association [TCCA] are continuing a series of meetings designed to inflame resistance to the lawful end to turf cutting on protected bogs next spring. They present themselves as ‘wholly innocent victims in this debacle', with the Government having ' ‘bullied, threatened, swindled and betrayed peace loving Turf Cutters'.

The Peatland Council has failed to disabuse the turf cutters of proposals they have made which are legally or scientifically impossible or impractical - including hydrological liners, de-designation, and relocation to bogs capable of restoration.

We debate the issue on the Pat Kenny Show with Luke Flannagan, the TD and spokesman for the TCCA. Read our proposal to give the turf cutters a Home Energy Programme worth up to €16,000, using the proposed compensation and grants available from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. This will tackle fuel poverty at its source and give the cutters generous recompense for their lose - an improved home that will save money on fuel far into the future.

And watch the video shown at the Ploughing Championship claiming that in spite of massive machinery 'turf cutting is continuing at the same pace through the generations'.

 

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 14/09/2011 ( Reads : 89 ) | Comments (0) | Peat Power
New EIA Regulations deplored
Friends of the Irish Environment - New EIA Regulations deplored

Moving the control of rural planning out of the Department of the Environment and into the Department responsible for massively  increased production goals - The Department of Agriculture - will be a costly exercise that will do nothing to protect the areas of the countryside that are most at risk. A spokesman for Friends of the Irish Environment said that ‘the high thresholds – given the average farm size in sensitive areas – and failure to address cumulative impact will ensure that Ireland’s biodiversity will continue to decline and many more archaeological monuments will vanish without a trace.’

The move has been announced in response to the threat of fines over the European Court Judgment in case C-66/06 which ruled that Ireland did not properly assess developments in the countryside. However, FIE welcomed the Minister’s announcement of key safeguards relating to wetlands, monuments, Natura 2000 sites, NHAs and proposed NHAs. These will trigger a screening requirement for EIA purposes independently of the thresholds.

 

READ OUR PRESS RELEASE AND THE MINISTER'S STATEMENT

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 08/09/2011 ( Reads : 93 ) | Comments (0) | Press Release
EU SEPTIC TANK FINE WARNING WELCOMED
Friends of the Irish Environment - EU SEPTIC TANK FINE WARNING WELCOMEDFIE has welcomed the clarification provided by the European Commission on the imposition of fines and penalties as long as Ireland fails to address poorly managed or controlled septic tanks which may cause significant harm to the environment and human health.

Deputy Éamon O'Cuiv recently suggested he would rather go to jail than pay for the proposed inspections and Marian Harkin MEP has organised a series of meetings in opposition to the EU Court requirements.

FIE has supplied information to the Comission which was used in these proceedings and has long sought an end to the practises which led to the construction of dwelling houses on soils unsuitable for septic tanks.

Senior council officials and Managers overruled the advice of their planners and many councillors supported motions to give development consent where the professional staff advised against it.

Any question of liability now must consider these factors. Because of the delay in dealing with these issues, Ireland is certain to receive its first environmental fine - it is now only a case of how much.

 

EU Statement

// Read More //

Posted By Tony Lowes on 31/08/2011 ( Reads : 92 ) | Comments (0) | One off houses